Book Review: Oblivious Investing

Blogs RSS
We've had quite a few commenters asking about investment returns, so we thought we should review a book that explores this topic.

Title: Oblivious Investing: Building Wealth by Ignoring the Noise
 

Author: Mike Piper
 

The Premise

Told as a parable-like tale, Oblivious Investing introduces you to Shannon, a young woman in her 20s who wants to start investing her money but doesn't know how. She decides to contact her financially savvy Uncle Toby for advice, and he proceeds to lay out the tenets of what he calls "oblivious investing."

At 113 pages, not including appendices, Oblivious Investing is a pretty quick read. In fact, you can learn almost everything you need to know about Oblivious Investing from the four-page Introduction. The rest of the book exists to attempt to walk the audience, the newbie investor, through some of the questions, mistakes, doubts, trials and tribulations of someone starting out in personal investing.
 

How Oblivious Investing works (from the Introduction)

The "simple, two-part strategy" Piper proposes:

  1. "Invest heavily in stocks via diversified, low-cost mutual funds."
  2. "Hold onto those funds for decades at a time, ignoring all the short-term fluctuations in the market." (p. 3)

This is also known as the "Buy and Hold" strategy, which is a fairly well-known investment strategy. As Piper notes, Oblivious Investing "isn't exciting. It isn't original. It is effective." (p. 3)

How can the oblivious investor be so sure of this strategy? Piper suggests that such confidence comes from a study of the stock market's historical performance. You may be familiar with the disclaimer, "past performance is not an indicator of future results." You might be wondering, then, why we should pay attention to the past performance of the stock market in order to determine why oblivious investing should work.

The difference, Piper argues, is that we're looking at the stock market as a whole, not just at a single stock or a single mutual fund. He writes that the best way to determine a good investment strategy is to study what has and hasn't work before. By doing so, he says, we learn the following:

  1. Over short periods of time, stock returns are extremely volatile and unpredictable.
  2. Over longer periods of time, however, this volatility decreases substantially.
  3. Over a long enough period of time, stocks (as a group) have nearly always outperformed bonds.
  4. Inflation – almost unnoticeable over a period of just a few years – has a very significant impact over an investor's lifetime.(p. 2)

But if Oblivious Investing is just a fancy name for the age-old "Buy and Hold" investing strategy, why did Piper write this book? Why does he feel it necessary to explain something as simple as "have a diversified investment portfolio and hold it for a long time"?

Well, because, Piper purports, Oblivious Investing can be a lot harder than you might think. It requires you, the investor, to block out all of the "noise."

If you follow the Oblivious Investing strategy, you have to figure out how to ignore news about how poorly the stock market did today, this month, or this year. You have to ignore people telling you how great this or that new stock is. And, possibly hardest of all, you have to ignore people (including friends and family) calling you crazy for ignoring all of the stuff that you're ignoring. All that matters to the long-term, oblivious investor are the four lessons listed above. (p.4)
 

What does Piper get right?

One of the things that I especially like about Oblivious Investing is how easy to understand it is, without being patronizing. Piper's character, Shannon, asks many questions a new investor might need or want to know, and her Uncle Toby is more than happy to answer them.

Oblivious Investing was published in 2009, which means that Piper takes the 2008-2009 Recession into consideration as he lays out the oblivious investing strategy. He uses the Recession as an example of the kind of noise you might get in the course of your long-term investment plan.

He also uses the Recession as an example of how investing automatically through a downturn can benefit you (this is called dollar cost averaging) by jumping a few years into Shannon's future to see how her Obliviously Invested portfolio has worked for her.
 

What does Piper get wrong?

The biggest issue with Oblivious Investing is that it is a strategy for long-term investing success that is based on an assumption. Oblivious Investing is based on the assumption that the stock market will continue to function, on a basic level, as it has always functioned.

Is this assumption wrong? We can't know.

Does the fact that Oblivious Investing is based on an assumption mean that you shouldn't follow the principles and tenets laid out by the author? No. If we assume that the stock market will continue to function as it has always functioned, Oblivious Investing is a solid investment strategy. Much more reliable than picking individual stocks or trying to beat or time the market, Piper argues repeatedly in "Part Two: The Noise."

It's true that Oblivious Investing is an investment strategy based on an assumption about the future performance of the stock market. More importantly, however, is that every investment strategy having to do with the stock market makes the same assumption.

The important thing to recognize is that the assumption exists, and there is no guarantee that it will hold true. That is the risk you take in investing in the stock market.

Piper's thesis is this: if the stock market performs the way it has always performed, Oblivious Investing is a smart strategy for building wealth.
 

So what makes Oblivious Investing different or better than one of the other thousand personal finance books out there?

The best thing about Oblivious Investing is the straight forward way the concepts are laid out and explained. If you read Oblivious Investing, by the time you are finished, you should have a solid understanding of the "Buy and Hold" strategy for growing your money by investing it in the stock market, and some good tools to drown out "the noise." Piper also does a good job of explaining investment risk and the various ways you can deal with risk.

I have read no other book on investing that has explained so clearly and so thoroughly the basics of "Buy and Hold" investing, including the common questions and challenges that all new investors have.
 

Conclusion

The engaging and straightforward writing style makes Oblivious Investing a quick, informative read. If you wanted to get one book that would get you started on understanding Investing without overwhelming you with information, Oblivious Investing is the book I would suggest… after completing the Education Cents course on Saving and Investing of course. :)
 

 
Posted by on 1/12/2012 10:30:00 AM
Current rating: 5 (1 ratings)
 
 

Join the conversation! Sign in to comment. Not registered? Register Now.

Trackback URL: http://www.educationcents.org/trackback/630389f8-a16e-4809-8066-273a6e56ede7/Book-Review-Oblivious-Investing.aspx?culture=en-US

Comments
an_templin@msn.com
as young adults, we tend to try and jump into things before understanding what they are. this short book not only helps to avoid that, but also helps to keep up with the short attention span that most teenagers have today.
4/19/2012 9:54:52 AM
 
tyler.n.lovely@gmail.com
If there's one thing I've learned about investing through this site; it's a little at a time, consistently, over a long time makes a big difference.
3/28/2012 12:18:15 PM
 
selliott0470@bvsd.org
This book sounds awesome! "How to" kinds of books so rarely don't sound patronizing or condescending! I'm a high school youngun but my dad is a Financial Planner and this "buy and hold" strategy sounds like something he tells people a lot. It sounds like it would work well for a lot of older people I know that get very attached to certain stocks they grew up around.
3/12/2012 4:28:43 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@giveitarivet -- Exactly. $5 a week (the cost of a meal out, or a cup of fancy coffee) is $25 a month, and that will add up over time.
2/29/2012 10:36:20 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
It does seem hard to invest when a person can barely meet their expenses now. I guess you start with $5.00.
2/28/2012 7:47:36 PM
 
shasha
Even though students or new grads don't have the income to invest, it is a great idea to read and learn about the options available. I am within 10 years of retirement. I have money in a 401(k) but wish I had been more actively involved earlier.
2/25/2012 8:26:29 PM
 
Avatar
b.myers@bresnan.net
I've been saving over the past year in preparation for college and other expenses I see coming. I want to invest a chunk of this savings but it doesn't seem smart to tie up money I might need in the near future. I would agree that it seems hard investing as a student where every dollar counts.
2/21/2012 8:40:08 AM
 
april.k.wilkerson@wellsfargo.com
I am glad to see so many authors taking an interest in teaching our young people how to invest and making it less fearful. We need to educate the young people so they make wiser choices than we did in our generation. We all learned by trial and error.
2/17/2012 9:31:05 AM
 
chavez.cesar88@yahoo.com
Thanks megan x) Oblivious Investing's gonna be on my to read list B)
2/14/2012 9:40:36 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
David Ramsey has some great ideas about how to manage your money.
2/12/2012 2:46:23 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@chavez.cesar88 -- I hate to sound flip, but my suggestion would be to read Oblivious Investing. It was written for people in exactly your situation. :)

You might also check out/review the "How to Invest" section of our Saving & Investing Course (http://bit.ly/z0EEEy) and check out this video, "Stock Markets in Plain English" (http://www.commoncraft.com/video/stock-markets).

If those don't answer your questions, let us know, and we'll see what else we can do to help.
2/9/2012 11:24:04 AM
 
chavez.cesar88@yahoo.com
If i could id be investing in the stock market but i dont know how to or even the fundamentals in the stock market :( any suggestions?
2/9/2012 9:11:36 AM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
One thing about the stock market, there is a good chance that there is a winner when there is a looser.
2/7/2012 2:46:30 PM
 
jbestle29@gmail.com
What isn't discussed a whole lot are the steps to making wise investments, that would probably be helpful in this context so that people aren't blindly investing on a whim.
2/6/2012 12:52:07 PM
 
greenprogressive@hotmail.com
It's true that equities are still not overvalued based on corporate earnings and savings. Profits that are not reinvested in production activity are being used to buy back stocks, sending prices up without any increase in earnings. This is also what the Fed's quantitative easing and low interest rate does, creating a hopefully well managed inflation to stimulate spending. Read Paul Krugman in the New York Times opinion for more Keynesian economic analysis.
2/6/2012 11:26:19 AM
 
Avatar
Megan
@rawhite -- I'm glad that we've helped pique your curiosity about investing. Good luck with your research.

@giveitarivet -- Life insurance can be viewed as an investment although not in the "traditional" stock market sense. If you want to learn more about it, the Life Insurance section (http://bit.ly/yOrYeO) of the Insurance course is a good place to start.

@jalafla500 -- As long as your research, a down economy can be a good time to find solid investments. As Warren Buffet says, "Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful."
2/6/2012 9:46:16 AM
 
jalafla500@yahoo.com
I have always been told that it is smart investment, especally in these economic times when you can pick up some good investments for cheep.
2/3/2012 10:13:09 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I was reading some of what Dave Ramsey speaks about investing and he says term life is the way to go. What do you think?
2/3/2012 8:37:36 AM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
It did shake my trust in our stock market when our government decided everyone's stock in chrysler was worthless, took over it and then a year later turned around and sold chrysler stock to the public,without giving the prior stock holders anything, I was stunned.
2/2/2012 10:00:59 PM
 
rawhite@mavs.coloradomesa.edu
I've never really been interested in investing but reading this blog makes me want to learn more do my research.
2/2/2012 4:31:25 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@marchfifteenth -- Considering the risk involved with an investment (or anything, really) and whether or not you can afford to take that risk is something that everyone should look at when making a decision.

Being well-informed about all of the various options and oportunities is the vesty way to make any decision.
2/1/2012 1:41:50 PM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
While you make a good point, something the readers should consider is an investment is considered unsuitable if a person does not have the financial ability to incur the risk associated with a particular investment.

Financial planners must have (when recommending to a customer the purchase of any security) reasonable grounds for believing that the recommendation is suitable upon the basis of the client's financial situation and needs.
Just saying..
1/31/2012 4:04:45 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@marchfifteenth -- We definitely understand that investing is not a high priority for many of our readers/users at this time. However, investing is a valuable tool, and something that we want everyone to understand, no matter if they're able to use it right now or not.

The better you understanding investing and compound interest, the better you will be set up for the future (and your eventual retirement). You may not be able to use this information now, but you will be able to use it eventually, and we want you to understand how it works.

Our goal, as always, is to prepare our readers/users for the future and to make them as financially savvy as possible. Understanding investing is important to being financially savvy.
1/30/2012 9:57:11 AM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
" hard to think about when you are living day to day on a college student budget."

This is what I'm saying too. The staff is hitting on a subject that applies to only a few of its readers. They need to reconsider the financial position of who they are marketing this site to.
1/28/2012 9:51:59 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
The high schools really should teach a class on this type of stuff. It would better prepare young people to be better consumers and investors. Otherwise you learn it by the seat of your pants or like this, and not everyone even knows about this website and great learning tool!
1/27/2012 4:34:12 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I am still not convinced to invest. I hate to lose the little I have. I guess Ishould read some more and save a little more....
1/26/2012 7:21:46 PM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
Good read for those who have or are about to graduate, since they will soon have expendable income. For most of the readers on this blog (those still getting their education and having minor expendable capital, I would suggest using their time to read their textbooks and leave such reading for later in life. Just my 2 cents
1/26/2012 10:44:41 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I like the idea of introducing this at the high school level. I think expanding the younger students knowledge will make them better investors later. Good idea!
1/25/2012 7:02:24 PM
 
Avatar
b.myers@bresnan.net
Mutual funds are amazing, but how does all this investing get balanced out. If everyone in a mutual fund is making, who is losing.
1/25/2012 8:22:36 AM
 
t4harrison@skybeam.com
Sounds like a good read for entry level investors. Perhaps it should be introduced even at the High School level. If nothing else, it will help to understand the terminology of that industry.
1/24/2012 9:52:53 AM
 
tasnimmm17@hotmail.com
im planning on putting away $50 dollars a month for 1 year and at the end of the year investing that. That will be a total of $600 dollars. It's not much but baby steps :)
1/21/2012 8:35:56 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
Investing is an interesting topic, but also hard to think about when you are living day to day on a college student budget. I owe I owe I owe...
1/21/2012 2:37:17 PM
 
Avatar
ranverr@aol.com
I don't trust giving my money to someone else then tell me when I can have access to my money and then tell me you may or may not get it back that's a huge risk
1/21/2012 10:16:40 AM
 
angela@switchcpr.com
Haven't read the book, but I started with a whole life policy, and an moving into single socks now
1/20/2012 11:38:17 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I am not so sure I feel comfortable investing in the stock market. I go for save investments, only if I have extra money. LIke $5 a month right now. College is so expensive it is hard to save. But I am trying to do it a little at a time. Great info.
1/20/2012 9:52:25 AM
 
Avatar
ranverr@aol.com
I don't trust the stock market either it's too unpredictable in my eyes. It's not fun giving your money away and not know for sure if you're going to hopefully at least breaking even or not.
1/20/2012 8:40:20 AM
 
Avatar
careabearasara@gmail.com
If i had extra funds TO invest I absolutely would, but money is tight!
1/19/2012 4:45:37 PM
 
ouisook@naver.com
If I have extra $1000, I will play with stock market to get some money...it real fun and learn.
1/18/2012 5:11:27 PM
 
greenprogressive@hotmail.com
Vanguard mutual funds are a good place to start. They have the lowest costs of the major fund managers. There is no substitute for being well informed on a daily basis. Some good sources of financial information are the business pages in major newspapers, Investor's Business Daily, the radio program "Marketplace" and the TV show "Nightly Business Report." If you are not interested in business and investing then "buy and hold" is the best you can do, but it is riskier than paying attention to what is happening and acting on that information with understanding.
1/17/2012 11:25:11 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@Rachel H. -- I can certainly understand your reluctance to trust the stock market, especially considering the events of recent years. Before you write off completely, you might look into the concept of "dollar cost averaging" (see link above) as a possible reason to invest even when the market is down.

@tasnimm17 -- Doing more research to understand investing is definitely a good idea. It's a good idea to be informed about what you're getting into if you decide to invest.

@Breanna.Dodge -- Even thinking about saving or investing when pinching pennies in college can be overwhelming. I know it's not something I was able to do, but I always wish I had.

As they say, the sooner you start, the better off you'll be. Even $5 a month can add up over the long haul. Something to think about.
1/17/2012 9:37:47 AM
 
Breanna.Dodge@hotmail.com
As a student entering my second semester of college I'm already pinching pennies. The "Buy and Hold" strategy may not help me out now, but I'm sure it could benefit me later on. I will need advice and Obvious Investing will be on my list of references.
1/16/2012 2:07:27 PM
 
mcowell@mines.edu
This seems like a good read on the subject of investing in the market. I wonder if anyone knows of good sources of information for investing in other areas like commodities. I've heard a lot of good things about gold lately.
1/16/2012 12:21:28 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
Interesting information. I still wonder about the stock market. Good info!!
1/16/2012 11:01:56 AM
 
littlenikki_2006@yahoo.com
If one is not familiar with investing or the stocks this would help out the young college students.Especially if they don't have anyone to help them out.
1/16/2012 10:49:25 AM
 
tasnimmm17@hotmail.com
investing is still a difficult topic for me. i feel like i have to do more research on it
1/15/2012 11:20:19 PM
 
Avatar
Rachel H.
It's interesting that he finished writing this book in 2008 right when the market crashed and businesses went bankrupt. I can't say I completely agree with his logic; to say that an investment over a long period of time is more stable and less volatile is obvious, but also deceptive because stability doesn’t always necessarily amount to profit, especially in the market and economy today. Like [book reviewer] said, " Oblivious Investing is based on the assumption that the stock market will continue to function, on a basic level, as it has always functioned." Today, I have little faith left in the stock market and I personally would not recommend any investments beyond maybe purchasing precious metals or buying a house (without taking out a large mortgage), which may give back a stable and considerable return. Any other investments carry a huge risk, the kind that a lot of people lost out ever since 2007.
1/14/2012 11:48:26 AM
 
j300zx@gmail.com
It might make the fear go away but the stock market does not seem like it's the best way to gain wealth.
1/13/2012 11:15:45 AM
 
aimeewilli11@gmail.com
I agree with epliszka - it does sound like a good read, especially for those not familiar with investing. I like the take the author writes from (Shannon) because in doing so, it makes the book seem more personable. Good review!
1/13/2012 10:46:44 AM
 
mcowell@mines.edu
I've heard over and over that long-term investing really makes sense - especially for young people. As a student it may be hard to come up with money to invest, but it sure can pay off.
1/13/2012 10:39:55 AM
 
epliszka@hotmail.com
Sound like an interesting read. This Information removes some of the fears of investing in the stock market, especially for young people.
1/12/2012 11:27:05 AM
 

Latest Blog Comments

5/16/2012
Eric
What cool projects you all have! you're the deserving winne...
5/15/2012
ethan
Congratulations to all the winners !!
5/14/2012
Rachel H.
The money tree really does exist! haha
5/13/2012
carl
I agree with carlaannott@yahoo.com it is very important to ...
5/11/2012
carl
All of these comments are such positive feedback. Kind of ...
5/11/2012
Nanci
Congrats, I have no idea what this is, but it look likes yo...
5/11/2012
Natasha
Congratulations winners!!! They are so beautiful!
Close

Please sign in

In order to save a page/activity in either your toolbox or favorites you must first be logged in.