Valentine’s Day and Emotional Spending

Blogs RSS
Valentine’s Day has come to be synonymous with spending money – often a lot of money – on your significant other. Everyone knows what you’re “supposed” to buy for your sweetie on Valentine’s Day, but have you ever stopped to ask yourself if you’re buying those things because society thinks that’s the best way to express your love, or because you actually find buying those things to be the best expression of your love?

We Spend and Spend and Spend

According to a survey done by the National Retail Federation, the average person will spend $126.03 on gifts and things this Valentine’s Day, and Americans are expected to spend a total of $17.6 billion. That’s a lot of money, especially if you’re on a budget.

Anyone in the business of selling anything knows that Valentine’s Day is a big spending day for a lot of people. You only have to see the ads on TV (or the radio, or in the Newspaper, or online) to know that there are tons of sales happening the weeks leading up to V-day. And these sales are for all sorts of goods, not just the flowers, jewelry and candy you might expect. For example, I was flipping through the weekly ads from my local grocery stores, and every single one has “great deals” on cuts of steak, so you can “treat your Valentine right,” even if you’re dining in.

Even clothing and electronic stores—which don’t really sell anything classically Valentine’s-related—are having big sales in the week before Valentine’s Day. I guess the theory is that if people are out shopping anyway, might as well entice them to stop by.

All of these advertisements and sales add to the societal pressure to spend money to express your love on Valentine’s Day. They play on the fact that emotional spending is often irrational spending, and when you’re spending money irrationally, you’re more likely to confuse “wants” with “needs” and spend more than you planned.
 

But Do We Need to Spend So Much?

We often spend money on our loved one on Valentine’s Day in an attempt to satisfy our upper-level needs in Maslow’s hierarchy.This spending may be intended to fulfill our love and belonging needs, or those of our significant other, or our belief that the amount of money we spend shows our “value as a human being,” fulfilling our esteem and ego needs.

This spending may feel motivated by needs, but it’s usually based on irrational beliefs. Thoughts like, “She won’t love me if I don’t buy her the biggest box of chocolates available,” or “He’ll think I don’t care if I don’t get him this gold watch,” might do more harm than good.

When it comes to Valentine’s Day, it’s important to remember that the people in your life will love you no matter how much (or little) you spend on them. It’s okay if you don’t buy the biggest box of chocolates, or the bouquet of two-dozen roses, or the gold watch, or the dinner for two at the fanciest restaurant in town. You don’t have to go broke or run up a big credit card bill just to say “I love you.”
 

Spend Consciously

Whether you’re spending a lot of money this Valentine’s Day, or just a little, it’s a good idea to make sure you think about why you’re spending. A big night out on the town can be lots of fun, and there’s nothing wrong with indulging within your means. But it can be all too easy to fall into the trap of feeling that if you don’t go “all-out,” your special someone will feel left out. In most cases, this is just not true! If your someone is truly special, they love you just for being you and the best gift for any holiday is your thoughtfulness and attention – in whatever form is meaningful and important to both of you.

In one of our original blogs, Andres explored love and money – it’s an oldie but a goodie!

If you want to do something special, but you don’t want to break the bank, here are a few resources:

And just for fun:


Happy Valentine’s Day!

 
Posted by Megan Taylor on 2/13/2012 10:30:00 AM
Current rating: 0 (0 ratings)
 
 

Join the conversation! Sign in to comment. Not registered? Register Now.

Trackback URL: http://www.educationcents.org/trackback/f4d8eee4-5efe-4943-915d-7501845eb596/Valentine’s-Day-and-Emotional-Spending.aspx?culture=en-US

Comments
Taarna_girl@hotmail.com
Well, people love to shower their loved one with sentimental gifts. Which can become very costly, in my opinion telling them how you fell is best. Chocolate doesnt hurt though :)
4/25/2012 5:15:00 PM
 
an_templin@msn.com
this is helpful to teach us about not over spending for someone even if we love them. if they truly love you, they wont care how much you spend. it is a good idea to remind us especially teenagers who are young and in love.
4/12/2012 9:48:11 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
Remember that the amount of money spend at any time does NOT show your value as a human being! It is so much more than that..
3/27/2012 11:39:24 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I think a lot of these tips could be used for holidays, all year!
3/26/2012 11:04:54 AM
 
heifetzjr@s.dcsdk12.org
I think this blog is great, so many people spend money on worthless items that are not needed, such as candys and flowers when most the time they up the prices.
3/22/2012 2:29:50 PM
 
avilalizbeth@yahoo.com
Sometimes it is better to give your significant other expensive or cutsi things scence it is only Valentines day and their birthday the day you have an "excuse" to give such details.
3/22/2012 11:25:14 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I like the idea of asking each other if you want me to buy you something or not. Lets save the money for something big or just to buy gas with so you can go to the mountains for a picnic.
3/20/2012 7:07:01 PM
 
Jennifer.J.Cooper@adams12.org
Good link! I worked at a expensive (fondue) restaurant in college and we charged double on Valentine's Day weekend!
3/20/2012 11:01:21 AM
 
Avatar
laxleehay@Gmail.com
You know i really don't think that Valentines Day is for a guy to buy his girl friends stuff day if you really want to show your love just take your girl out, i don't know wheare to but you cant even take here to your mom's house and cooke her a nice dinner or something, is not always buying candys, fllowers, or a teddybear jus do something that is simple, you don't even have to spend money.
3/12/2012 7:12:58 PM
 
gtz_karla@hotmail.com
Trying to save money is a good idea... Handmade gifts are a good way of achieving this idea its fun and creative and you get to express yourself more then if you buy it at a store...:)
3/12/2012 7:12:51 PM
 
sabrego44@yahoo.com
I think just by being with that special person all day and telling them you love them is the most wonderfull gift...not just buying your gf or bf a gift
3/12/2012 7:10:22 PM
 
selliott0470@bvsd.org
SNB, I totally agree! I think experiences are much more memorable than "things." Plus, in twenty years you won't be throwing away the clutter that some gifts have made, you'll be remembering some fun times!
3/11/2012 1:06:19 PM
 
Avatar
SNB
small things mean more to me than anything else:)
3/5/2012 7:57:55 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@kyle.f.walsleben -- Yeah, you definitely don't want to assume anything about what your significant other wants or doesn't want. My husband and I had our "Valentine's spending" conversation several weeks before the day, so we both knew what to expect.

@elizabethbollig1994 -- Being thoughtful about what you give can be a great way to do something nice without spending a lot of money.

@tylerbuhr_85 -- It's definitely important to have a conversation and communicate your priorities with your significant other.
3/1/2012 10:14:40 AM
 
tylerbuhr_85@hotmail.com
I actually asked my GF if we should buy stuff for eachother and we didn't and saved a lot of money!
2/29/2012 6:05:26 PM
 
elizabethbollig1994@gmail.com
I think that Valentines day is the second most expensive holiday of the year. I believe that we shouldn't have to buy the people we love something to show how much we love them. Doing something simple such as cleaning, cooking a meal, or doing something special is a better way of showing the love then spending every dollar we earn to get someone something.
2/29/2012 1:13:17 PM
 
Tyler
Good post. It has me thinking.
2/29/2012 12:48:58 PM
 
kyle.f.walsleben@gmail.com
I agree its a corporate money maker but don't be the husband that doesn't buy something for your wife or you will never hear the end of it :)
2/29/2012 12:40:44 PM
 
lbl1994@live.com
I think that Valentines Day makes people feel obligated to buy things. It's just a corporate money maker!
2/29/2012 8:36:39 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
Words and homemade cards go a long way I think! WHy spend all that money?
2/27/2012 5:53:02 PM
 
Avatar
ranae.call@gmail.com
Well, if they don't get you anything, then you shouldn't get them a single thing.
2/27/2012 10:08:21 AM
 
quaidwins15@yahoo.com
i felt same about homemade gifts.....not because it is cheaper but it came from the heart and took more thought than just going and spending money on a cheap gift
2/27/2012 9:01:16 AM
 
shasha
I believe "holidays" such as Valentine's Day are only for the benefit of retailers. My husband has no income at the moment, so anything he buys for me is being bought with my money. Not much of a gift. I believe in loving words and actions all year long, not just when Hallmark says it's time.
2/25/2012 8:14:22 PM
 
april.k.wilkerson@wellsfargo.com
We encouraged our family this year to make gifts and just a small box of candy this year instead of a big one. We went for pancakes at the local pancake house and had a great time and did not have to break the bank.
2/24/2012 4:13:29 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I like the idea of always giving handmade things, not just because its cheaper(maybe) but because it is fun and I think it means more!
2/22/2012 7:15:58 PM
 
Avatar
chokentrolls42@gmail.com
I think it's great that more and more people seem to realize the advantages and rewards of creating your own gifts. Hopefully this isn't just a sign of people being frugal due to the bad economy, but is also the result of a change in values and overall outlook on material possessions.
2/22/2012 1:53:35 AM
 
Avatar
beachponymisty@comcast.net
Homemade gifts are the best =)
2/21/2012 3:06:52 PM
 
Avatar
tech8384@hotmail.com
I definitely agree that it's the thought that counts, and that the best gifts in life are the ones that come from the heart and not your bank account. It takes a lot more to show somebody you know who they are and what makes them beat by creating something special rather than buying a material object from a store (that someone else is likely to have). This is a great blog though, and very well written :) thank you for sharing this!
2/21/2012 2:38:44 AM
 
majors0080@msn.com
We don't spend much on Valentine's Day - cards or a note is the extent of it - showing love and respect every day is our answer to Valentine's Day!
2/20/2012 7:22:12 AM
 
Avatar
pc.budano
In my relationship, I made it clear that I felt that Valentine's Day was unnecessary. Sorry if this offends anyone, but I feel that this is just another excuse for your significant other--specifically women--to ask for gifts to show off to their friends and brag about how loved they are. I told my boyfriend NOT to spend money on because he shows me how much he loves me every day, and it means a lot more when the gifts we get each other are random and not given on a specific day just because that is what you are SUPPOSED to do. On, or around, this "holiday" stores raise their prices on roses, chocolates, and what not. It is a complete waste of money just to prove your love ONE day.
2/19/2012 8:59:03 PM
 
tasnimmm17@hotmail.com
this makes me think of my marriage anniversary. i tend to go all out and spend so much on my husband, while my husband still spends a good amount, just nowhere near how much i spend. i feel like im having a competition with myself or something to try to get the best things for him because i love him so much. this year i am really going to try not to do that.
2/18/2012 11:27:35 PM
 
deherrera.olivia@gmail.com
Being broke college students my boyfriend and I just enjoy being together. I can relate to marchfifteenth@yahoo.com, being far away from someone is a huge expense. We don't do holiday gifts, just seeing one another for breaks.
2/18/2012 11:23:54 PM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
I would much rather have something homemade than a store baught Valentine anyday! WHy do people have to put so much emphasis on VDay anyway...... hugs and kisses always!!!
2/17/2012 8:38:54 PM
 
Avatar
aaninye@mscd.edu
there are some really good ideas here
2/17/2012 10:52:48 AM
 
Avatar
Megan
@marchfifteenth -- I've glad you found the links and advice useful. Thanks for saying.
2/17/2012 8:33:04 AM
 
giveitarivet@yahoo.com
Homemade gifts and coupons are great.
2/16/2012 6:14:53 PM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
Just got done looking at some of your website links that show how to do something special, but not break the bank. Between them and their post, there are some really good ideas. Saving this page to my favorites for later days.
2/16/2012 4:57:03 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@M'shell -- I love the idea of cards and coupons for things you will do for family. My cousin, who is a master in the kitchen, made a coupon book for our grandma offering to cook her dinner and bake her favorite dessert, etc.

@jan-ethan -- I love your powerpoint idea! That's fabulous. "As long as you have a good imagination, the best gifts in life are free," is a great way to think about gift-giving, no matter what time of year it is. :)
2/15/2012 9:49:08 AM
 
jan-ethan@hotmail.com
I think thta it is always the thought that counts. I made my hubby a powerpoint presentation, with pictures of us throughout the years and he loved it! As long as you have a good imagination the best gifts in life are free!
2/14/2012 10:23:48 PM
 
M'shell
I think that feeling like you "have to" spend money is really hard when on a budget. I have started doing and making more things for any of the special holidays. I just called friends and asked how they were and if there was anything that I could help them with today. I make myself available to run errands if need be. I also give home-made coupons, these can get very creative. Make one in the shape of a heart with something that you will do written inside!
2/14/2012 3:48:06 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
Yeah, when I told my husband I didn't want him to get me anything for Valentine's Day this year, he gave me a look that said "Yeah, right."

I did eventually convince him I was serious, but it can sometimes be tricky to figure out what your significant other is *actually* trying to tell you.
2/14/2012 2:39:03 PM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
This is a real touch and go subject though. The first year we did something like this, she was really mad at me. The message I heard was don't go waste a bunch of our money on this holiday. Its not worth it. Apparently the message she was sending me was..(get me something..implied), dont waste a bunch of our money on flowers. They aren't worth it. ...OOPS!
2/14/2012 2:29:56 PM
 
Avatar
Megan
@marchfifteenth -- Good call. I was delighted to get flowers from my husband on my birthday last year, but saddened to realize just how much such floral arrangements cost. We talked about it, and I decided that what I really appreciated most was the gesture, becuase it showed he was thinking of me.

Now, when he wants to do something nice to surprise me, he brings home a book I've been wanting to read or a movie I've had on my "DVDs to own" list for a while. The gesture is the same, and says "I love you" just as much as a bouquet, but costs less and last longer.
2/13/2012 2:25:08 PM
 
Avatar
marchfifteenth@yahoo.com
My wife and I agreed, better to offset some of the expense of me flying to Florida to see her for spring break than to send flowers to her at work on Valentine's day.
2/13/2012 12:48:55 PM
 

Latest Blog Comments

5/16/2012
Eric
What cool projects you all have! you're the deserving winne...
5/15/2012
ethan
Congratulations to all the winners !!
5/14/2012
Rachel H.
The money tree really does exist! haha
5/13/2012
carl
I agree with carlaannott@yahoo.com it is very important to ...
5/11/2012
carl
All of these comments are such positive feedback. Kind of ...
5/11/2012
Nanci
Congrats, I have no idea what this is, but it look likes yo...
5/11/2012
Natasha
Congratulations winners!!! They are so beautiful!
Close

Please sign in

In order to save a page/activity in either your toolbox or favorites you must first be logged in.